Sin in the Second City

Sin in the Second City: Madams, Ministers, Playboys, and the Battle for America’s Soul is a North American social history book by Karen Abbott. First published in 2007, Sin in the Second City covers the rise and downfall of America’s most famous brothel and how it changed the face of Chicago forever. Critics praise the book for its ability to educate and entertain simultaneously, and Abbott herself is recognized for her thorough research. It is Abbott’s debut work and a New York Times best seller. Abbott worked as a journalist before writing full time. She writes about famous—and often scandalous—women.

Sin in the Second City centers around the Everleigh Club and its owners. This establishment was one of the best-known brothels in Chicago in the early 1900s. It was founded in 1900 and closed in 1912 after a culture war against vice, indulgence, and sexuality shuttered its doors. Abbott explores why the brothel collapsed and the effect its demise had on Chicago, and America, going forward.

The book, however, is more than just a history of the Everleigh Club itself. Abbott introduces readers to the Everleigh sisters, the women who owned and managed the brothel. Minna and Ada, two aristocratic women, scoured Chicago for the perfect location for their club, and they found it in the Levee district—notorious for its corruption and scandalous nightlife.



When the women first opened the club, they had a very clear agenda: to civilize the industry and elevate the status of courtesans everywhere. Abbott’s thesis is that, from the moment the club opened its doors, it was doomed to fail because of Progressive Era reformers and their very different agenda. She sympathizes with the Everleigh sisters and believes that they’re often misunderstood by social historians attempting to understand the culture clash.

At the center of it all, Abbott explains, are the politicians. The politicians who so happily visited the brothel and used its services also campaigned against corruption and sexual degradation. One day they might be inside the club; the next, they were outside encouraging the reformers. Politicians encouraged royal patrons and dignitaries to indulge themselves in the brothel, all while pretending to be against it. Ultimately, the Everleigh Club could never succeed.

Abbott describes the Everleigh Club and its courtesans in some detail. She describes how clean and professional the club was, and notes that the girls were always paid properly. They were fed, cared for, and even encouraged to read and attend college. These girls were far from the poor, exploited slaves that reformers made them out to be.



Sin in the Second City also tells the story of the girls who made up the brothel’s ranks and what attracted them to the profession. There were girls with nowhere else to go, who knew they were better in the Everleigh Club than anywhere else in Levee. There were others who, like the Everleigh sisters themselves, wanted to shed their old identities and find new ones.

On the other hand, there were the men who frequented the club, and the ones who stole business from it on behalf of other madams, such as Ed and Louis Weiss, who worked for the club’s biggest rival. There were pastors and religious men who held sermons outside the club every night, hoping to bring the girls back to God. The Levee district was changing, and Abbott covers every facet of it until the club’s downfall.

Abbott criticizes reformers for choosing a high-profile target, such as the Everleigh Club, instead of attacking the smaller, hidden dens of ill repute that genuinely enslaved girls and turned them into sexual property. Abbott acknowledges that many girls at the time were kidnapped and sold into prostitution or sex work, but she stresses that the Everleigh Club was an exception.



It wasn’t just reformist zeal that the Everleigh sisters fought against for ten years. Women within their own ranks challenged them, too. Not everyone wanted to elevate the status of brothels and courtesans, and many women believed the Everleigh sisters were sabotaging their profession. For example, rival madams in establishments across the Levee district conspired to frame the the women for murder, and they started rumors of white slavery within the club. The sisters faced challenges from every side. Instead of finding allies, they found enemies.

At the heart of this culture clash, Abbott explains, is the tension between America’s puritanical roots and its hedonism. Nowhere is this conflict more obvious than the fight between brothel madams and Progressive Era reformers. Abbott believes that the Everleigh Club embodies the struggle between the old and the new. It stands for the problems between collective and personal identity, and how the transition from one era to another is never easy.