Hazel waits at Sonny’s cottage while the police take her statement. Gage is surprised that Hazel has returned to town, and exasperated that she keeps trying to find Jamie even after Caden insisted that she stop. Hazel doesn’t tell her brother about the photo of Audrey’s car. Instead, she goes to her uncle’s law office. Roy immediately recognizes the car in the picture but can’t remember any of the details of Audrey’s disappearance that will help Hazel get to the bottom of the mystery.

By the time Hazel returns home, Serena is waiting to question her. The detective tracked down Joe Lyons, who says he never saw Libby Sharp again after she stole a diamond ring and left him years earlier. Hazel shows Serena the photo of Audrey’s car, and they compare it to the photo of the first car pulled out of the lake. Serena takes the photo to follow up on the lead. Later, Keira calls about the photos of the house that Hazel sent her. She’s interested in rehabbing it but wants another picture without somebody standing inside. Hazel is shocked to realize that while she was taking photos of the house exterior, somebody was moving around indoors.